When I first tried this liner, I LOVED it! Then I used it on my waterline... it does not stay on and I had to reapply several times! For other than the waterline I would recommend it!

These are great, long wearing, very pigmented, and oh sooooooo smooth. I do not feel these are a dupe of the Urban Decay, I feel these are there own and again very affordable. I have black and white, just ordered a few more colors, and another black because I'm scared to run out!

I own both of the black colored pencils and I love these! These pencils are creamy and remind me of the texture of a gel eyeliner, but in pencil form. They don't budge whatsoever and are very long lasting, having even stayed on through multiple hand washes and a shower. These are definitely on par or better than higher end pencils.

Last night I stopped by Ulta and bought this liner in Jet Black. This morning I applied it and was amazed! It applied so easily and didn't tug at the skin at all, and the color was uber-intense! It also worked wonders on my water line and didn't budge at all. It's perfect for any occasion and comes many colors to match any look or outfit! My favorite part is how affordable it is! Thanks NYX! I'll definitely be buying more!

I have all but 6 of these colours and they blow the competition out of the water. By competition, I mean Gosh, UD and MAC in that order. The colours are true and vibrant on even the darkest complexions and even the metallics are not patchy in their coverage. The liners go on without pulling the skin of the eyelids, but are incredibly long lasting. I don't generally use this sort of liner on waterlines, so I can't comment on that. I would suggest that NYX add lilac, powder blue, lime green and navy blue to the range - they are the only colours I was looking for that are missing.

These pencils last just as long as more expensive brands' versions. I have black & brown perfection and they're both fabulous all day on my pale skin.

I was a die hard buyer of waterproof pencils from two other very well known brands. But these are actually identical or better to those, pretty much the same size and half the price. The Jet Black color is much much blacker than a "Zero" liner from another brand. I'm going to be buying these from now on.

these are great long lasting and very pigmented

These pencils are super smooth and creamy with great staying power. As a contact lens wearer though, these are no good for the water line. The product slid around on my contact and caused blurriness. I also had to use eyedrops and blink a great deal to try and maintain clarity in my vision. Clearly I can only use these for lining the top of my lid. Other than that, they're pretty great.