One of the best gift ideas for a loved one who adores makeup is, well, more makeup. If you’ve got a total beauty buff on your holiday shopping list, there’s no shortage of NYX Professional Makeup products you can get them for the holidays. Of course, we do have a few specific options we recommend for a truly standout holiday gift. One is the Mrs. Claus Matte Lip Vault. Starring our beloved Suede Matte Lipstick, this holiday gift set includes 14 individual lipsticks packed with velvety-plush matte color. Or, snag a few limited-edition eyeshadow palettes for them to play with (we recommend this year’s Mrs. Claus Oh Deer! Eyeshadow Palettes).

There is no universal “best” beauty gift to give—it depends on the person you’re gifting it to! If they’re a lover of all things lip, treat them to a lip makeup set, like the Mrs. Claus Butter Gloss Vault —it features 14 shades of our fan-favorite Butter Lip Gloss in one adorable holiday package. Or, for someone who tends to prefer no-makeup makeup, our Electrolyte Trio is a great option. Included in the three-piece set is Plump Right Back Primer + Serum and Plump Finish Setting Spray, plus the ultra-juicy This Is Juice Gloss for shiny, hydrated lips.

If you’re looking for the best makeup set to gift your loved one this holiday season, we suggest snagging our Mrs. Claus 24 Day Advent Calendar. Like a traditional advent calendar, this gift provides an interactive way to count down the days from December 1st until Christmas Eve—only, instead of greeting each day with chocolates or toys, they’ll get to open a new NYX Professional Makeup favorite each day. It’s truly the gift that keeps on giving, and for a beauty lover, is the ultimate holiday present. Get the classic 24-day calendar (or for a last-minute gift, the 12-day calendar) and watch as they unwrap a new surprise each day.

Stocking stuffers don’t have to only be for stockings—you can also DIY your own makeup gift basket by snagging a bunch of individual products and building your own curated collection. What products you’ll want to include in this depend on your giftee (and budget), but we recommend loading it with a few crowd-pleasers, such as the Lip Lingerie XXL Trio and Jumbo Eye Pencil Trio .