Waterproof and long-wear makeup—especially mascara—can be stubborn to remove, and scrubbing at your eyes is never a good idea. To remove your makeup, using a waterproof makeup remover is your best bet, since these formulas are designed to melt away makeup without the need for harsh rubbing.
Ahead, we’ll explain why a dedicated makeup remover is a must for long-wear formulas like mascara, eyeliner, and even long-wear lipstick. Then, we’ll show you exactly how to use our best makeup remover for waterproof makeup, The Face Unglue Makeup Remover Cleansing Balm, for a fresh, comfortable complexion.
Why Waterproof Makeup Is Harder To Remove
Waterproof and long-wear makeup is formulated to cling tightly to skin and lashes, resisting water, sweat, and humidity. These formulas often contain waxes, polymers, and oils that help them stay in place, which makes them more stubborn than regular makeup. That’s why water-based cleansers alone often can’t fully lift or break down these products—they’re simply not strong enough to melt away the strong gripping agents in the makeup.
What Removes Waterproof Makeup Effectively?
Not all makeup removers are created equal, especially when it comes to waterproof and long-wear formulas. Oil-based cleansers, cleansing balms, bi-phase removers, and micellar water can all help remove makeup, but they work in very different ways.
Oil-based formulas are the most effective for waterproof makeup because, as the saying goes, like dissolves like: the oils in these removers break down the waxes, pigments, and other long-wear ingredients, letting them lift off the skin without harsh rubbing. However, if you’re using an oil-based makeup remover for waterproof mascara or eyeliner, it’s important to take care around your eye area, as the oil may migrate into your eyes and cause (temporary) blurriness. Cleansing balms can be an excellent alternative, as they’re more solid in texture than liquid oils and therefore unlikely to migrate into your eyes.
Why Use a Cleansing Balm for Waterproof Makeup?
Cleansing balms are particularly effective for stubborn waterproof makeup because they dissolve mascara, eyeliner, and long-wear products on contact, lifting them from lashes and skin without tugging or rubbing. Unlike wipes or scrubbing with harsh cleansers, balms are gentle, thorough, and help prevent irritation around the delicate eye area.
If you’re looking for a cleansing balm to add to your skincare routine, we suggest The Face Unglue Makeup Remover Cleansing Balm. It starts off as a buttery balm and emulsifies upon contact with water, transforming into a silky, lightweight oil that rinses off easily, taking your waterproof and long-wear makeup with it. The unique formula also helps nourish the skin, leaving it feeling soft, comfortable, and hydrated for up to 24 hours.
Can oil-based makeup removers clog pores?
Oil-based removers don’t typically clog pores, but it is possible, depending on the formula used. If you’re acne-prone, always check the label to make sure your product is non-comedogenic (The Face Unglue Makeup Remover Cleansing Balm, for example, won’t clog your pores). If you’re especially worried about breakouts, be sure to fully emulsify your makeup remover with water before rinsing. You can also try double-cleansing, which involves washing your face once with an oil-based cleanser to melt makeup and sunscreen, then once more with a water-based cleanser to remove any lingering residue or impurities.
How To Remove Waterproof Makeup With a Cleansing Balm
Here’s a clear, step‑by‑step method for removing stubborn waterproof makeup using a cleansing balm:
- Start with dry skin: Scoop a generous amount of cleansing balm and smooth it onto dry skin—don’t wet your face first. This allows the balm to start breaking down waterproof products right away.
- Massage gently: Use your fingertips to massage the balm onto your face in small, circular motions, focusing on areas with heavy waterproof makeup (like the lashes and closed eyes). This helps dissolve mascara and liner without tugging.
- Hold briefly before wiping: Let the balm sit on your eyes for a few seconds so it can really melt the long‑wear makeup. Then, with your eyes closed, use a soft, damp cloth or cotton pad to wipe everything away.
- Emulsify and rinse: Splash a little lukewarm water onto your face to emulsify the balm into a silky texture, then rinse thoroughly.
- Optional double cleanse: If you want extra confidence that all residue is gone, follow up with your regular water‑based cleanser to remove any lingering traces. From there, you can proceed with your skincare routine, applying your toner, serum, and moisturizer as usual.
Removing waterproof mascara without damaging your lashes
Even the best makeup remover for waterproof mascara can be damaging if used incorrectly. Waterproof formulas cling tightly to lashes, and pulling or scrubbing can cause breakage or irritation.
To protect your lashes, patience is key. Apply an oil-based balm or remover to the lashes and let it sit for a few seconds to soften the mascara before attempting to wipe it away. Use gentle, downward motions with a soft cloth or cotton pad, and avoid rubbing back and forth.
By letting the product do the work instead of tugging, you can remove even stubborn mascara while keeping your lashes healthy, full, and intact.
Can You Remove Waterproof Makeup Without Makeup Remover?
Technically, it’s possible to remove waterproof makeup without a dedicated remover in a pinch—gentle oil, coconut oil, or even a bit of micellar water can lift some product. However, these methods are less effective at dissolving stubborn formulas like waterproof mascara or long-wear eyeliner. Trying to remove waterproof mascara without makeup remover can be especially tricky, as the eye area is delicate and prone to irritation.
For consistent, thorough results, a cleansing balm is your most reliable option. These unique cleansers are specifically formulated to melt away long-wear makeup gently, protecting delicate skin and lashes while leaving your face clean and comfortable.
Is Micellar Water Enough for Removing Waterproof Makeup?
Micellar water can help remove light makeup and surface impurities, but it typically isn’t strong enough to fully dissolve waterproof mascara or other long-wear eye products. It may lift some pigment, but stubborn formulas often remain on lashes or along the waterline.
For waterproof makeup, micellar water is best used as a supplement—for example, as a final wipe after using an oil-based remover or cleansing balm, rather than as your primary method of removal.
Common Mistakes To Avoid When Removing Waterproof Makeup?
Even with the right remover, it’s easy to make small errors that can irritate your eyes or damage lashes. Being mindful of these common missteps can help you remove waterproof makeup safely and effectively:
- Scrubbing or tugging at lashes and eyes: This can lead to irritation, redness, and lash breakage. Use a gentle hand and be patient.
- Using dry cotton pads or tissues: Dry cotton pads won’t lift makeup effectively and may irritate delicate skin. Dampen the cotton pad before swiping it over your skin for a comfortable and effective makeup removal process.
- Skipping a follow-up cleanse: Skipping a second cleanse can leave residue behind, which may clog pores or cause irritation. Even if it’s just going over your face with micellar water or toner, it’s a good idea to give your face a quick wipe down to make sure all product residue is removed before layering on your serum and moisturizer.
- Rushing the process: Not allowing the remover to soak in first can make stubborn makeup harder to remove and tempt you to rub harder.
Avoiding these mistakes helps keep your lashes healthy, your eyes comfortable, and your skin feeling fresh—and well-prepped for your next makeup application. .
Next: How To Sweat and Waterproof Your Eyebrows.
We want to see how you use your NYX cleansing balm! Share your routine on social and tag us @nyxcosmetics.
PRODUCTS USED
The Face Unglue Makeup Remover Cleansing Balm
Up to 24HR hydration. Maintains skin barrier.
